Mine had 3 wheels back side black, and 1 side back was just like the front. The black looked to be the original coating as did the silver, I assume the Silver back was a service wheel. My spare was was redone with a powder coating. The powder coated one has more tiny specks of flake like sparkle to it then the ones that I redid with a spray bomb Argent Silver from Eastwood. The powder coating also has a tad goldish hue noticable only really when you put it next to the ones repainted with the spraybomb. The powder coated one also matches the one that was painted silver on the backside in color. Interesting color variation, not sure which of the two silvers is correct, but I can tell you for sure, the color and sparkle on the powder coated one is definitely the best looking of the set I have. I'd take a photo and share it but doubt the subtle difference would show up on camera.